Senior decision-makers come together to connect around strategies and business trends affecting utilities.


Electric Vehicles Providing Challenges and Opportunities for Utilities

image credit: © Alexander Naumov |
Dennis  Odegaard's picture
Utility Operations and Customer Service Expert, PA Consulting

Dennis Odegaard has 19 years of Electric Utility experience, specializing in distribution operations, distribution design, project management, and customer services. Prior to joining PA in 2019...

  • Member since 2020
  • 2 items added with 2,781 views
  • Apr 7, 2020

Transportation is continually moving towards electrification. Two million electric vehicles (EVs) were sold in 2018.  Forecasts predict EV sales to reach 10 million vehicles annually by 2025, and 28 million by 2030. With the extraordinary increase in EVs, there will need to be charging infrastructure to accommodate these vehicles and reduce customer range anxiety.  Publicly accessible charging stations will need to be supplied with appropriate connections and necessary electrical circuit capacity to integrate them into the distribution grid. This will obviously create challenges, but also opportunities, for electric utilities. With charging networks still in their relative infancy, we believe now is the time for utilities to develop a strategy as to how they can accommodate the increase and position themselves as the trusted provider to benefit from the need for EV charging. 

New load growth challenges and opportunities for utilities

Historically, load growth was the top priority of electric utilities.  In this case, integrating EV charging networks new load will be more challenging than adding traditional load growth entities (residential/commercial establishments) in the past. Charging stations will have different peak load profiles than previous historical trends of common residential or commercial load profiles. Peak demand will occur in discreet pocket sections on the distribution grid, driven by customers’ daily commutes, demographics, and retail charging options providing different profiles, demand curves, and input into the localized network peaks. The distribution grid will need to be more flexible than ever before, which will lead to investment opportunities for the utility when upgrading and enabling this flexibility. These investments can be direct contributors to increased reliability and customer satisfaction overall, through new automated switching devices, upgraded sensors and communication equipment, advanced metering infrastructure, and enhanced operations and monitoring software.  Established grid flexibility will enable and facilitate the growth of the EV industry and market penetration, enhancing how a utility can capitalize on EV opportunities and satisfy customer needs.

Further, building in this flexibility can allow the utility to utilize EVs themselves to aid in the management of peak loads and area outages via vehicle to grid (V2G) discharging.  An unused and charged EV can be used as a small generation device by discharging the stored energy back into the grid. This strategy will help enable carbon reduction goals, objectives that many utilities already have in place, and drive brand loyalty for other services that utilities provide.

New rate making opportunities

The uniqueness of this “new” load and need to service it strategically is an opportunity for utilities to help shape the coming rates around EV charging before these rates are instead imposed upon the utility by their respective commission with little or no input from the utility.  EV rates can be shaped in a way which would benefit both consumers and the utility. They can be designed to encourage consumers to discharge via V2G for spot outages or local peak demand intervals. Rates can incentivize customers to curb their own peak demand through V2G discharging, saving themselves energy costs and applicable demand charges. 

Capital investments in EV charging stations can create another revenue path

A major driver for utility revenue traditionally is capital investment in network assets. Utilities can earn a commission approved rate of return on their recent, or projected capital asset investments depending on how the utility’s rate making methodology is approved with their respective commission. Constructing and owning a local EV charging network, where the utility already knows the best and least expensive places to connect and integrate into their own system, is another way of responsibly increasing capital investment for the benefit of customers and the utility alike. Beyond the capital investment into the charging network, usage fees and advertising screens built into the charging station can provide supplemental revenue. Another avenue is pairing new EV charging stations with strip mall-like retail and restaurant storefronts, which will attract more customers to charge while shopping or using services at these locations. Conceivably, the utility could own the entire premise and rent out the storefronts as another method of diversified revenue stream via an affiliated non-utility entity. 

The greater path for capital investment is the distribution grid itself. These new dynamic loads will require significant infrastructure upgrades. Automated devices, smart sensor deployment, advanced metering infrastructure, and additional switching capabilities will all be required to add the necessary flexibility the grid will need to accommodate EV charging stations, regardless of whether the utility decides to build out their own charging network. These significant additions and upgrades will provide a long-term revenue stream based on approved rates of return by the utility’s commission. These investments need to be part of an overall asset management and modernization integrated resource plan.

EVs are here, and the wave will only grow stronger as time passes. Now is the time for utilities to plan and create their own strategies to prepare and facilitate the growth and integration of EVs into the transportation industry. Utilities will be key to the successful penetration of EVs into local markets and can grab hold of this opportunity to provide consistent revenue growth for future years.  We believe this is an important timeframe in the transition to electrification where utilities can secure their future financially and begin to shape their existence as a platform of enablement for future technologies.

Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Apr 7, 2020

Now is the time for utilities to plan and create their own strategies to prepare and facilitate the growth and integration of EVs into the transportation industry.

I absolutely agree with this, and I think it's a common sentiment, but still rollout sometimes seems like it's going slowly. Is there a risk of utilities not wanting to overcommit early (to a given technology, strategy, etc.) because they think there's a chance the real pathway pivots in a different direction and their investment will be lost? Or is the slow rollout more just a sign of how the market is only really starting to warm up to EVs?

Dennis  Odegaard's picture
Dennis Odegaard on Apr 8, 2020

Hi Matt,

I believe it is more of the latter.  There are enough reasons for a utility to create a Grid Modernization roadmap at this point beyond just EV market penetration. These reasons include better reliability, resiliency to outages, and overall customer satisfaction; all reasons for which state commissions are willing to hear.

Fully modernizing a grid can take many years, which is why now is a perfect time to plan as EV sales are starting to gather steam, along with the previously mentioned consumer benefits, and not even mentioning the growth of distributed energy resources (smaller solar farms, battery storage, and the like).  It's also a healthy and customer-conscious way for the utility to secure years of stable revenue and rate of return.  A win-win for both sides.

Dennis  Odegaard's picture
Thank Dennis for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network® is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »