Skip to content
  • EC Webcasts
  • Power Perspectives™
  • Special Issues
  • PowerSessions™
  • Sponsors
  • Home
  • Community
    • Q&A
    • Posts
    • Members
    • Experts
  • Groups
    • The Power Industry Network™

      Utility Business Network
      EnergyBiz® Network
      • Utility Professionals
      • Utility Management 
      • Customer Care 
      • HR & Recruitment
      • Resource Management
      Generation Network
      Generation Network
      • Generation Professionals
      • Clean Power Group
      Energy Management Network
      Energy Management Network
      • Load Management
      • Energy Efficiency
      Intelligent Utility Network
      Intelligent Utility® Network
      • Digital Utility
      • Mobile Workforce
      Grid Network
      Grid Network
      • Grid Professionals
      • Transmission Professionals
      Energy & Sustainability Network
      Energy & Sustainability
      Network
      • The Energy Collective
      • Oil & Gas Professionals
      • Clean Energy Business Network
      • Enel Foundation
  • Topics
  • Jobs
  • News
  • Calendar
  • Resources
    • Podcasts
    • Case Studies
    • White Papers
    • Recorded Webinars
  • Subscribe
  • More
    • Subscribe
  • ×
  • Create new content
    • Sign In
    • Apply for Membership
Part of Energy & Sustainability Network »

The Energy Collective Group

This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.

Join
  • Home
  • Posts
  • Q&A
  • Calendar
  • News
  • Members
  • Experts
  • Sponsors
Author Profile
Richard Brooks's picture
Richard Brooks
Co-Founder and Lead Software Engineer Reliable Energy Analytics LLC
Follow
Contact

About me

Successful developer of Energy Industry B2B and Cyber security standards at North American Energy Standards Board (NAESB) (www.naesb.org) since 1995; ANSI Meritorious Service Award Recipient;...

  • Member since 2018
  • 940 items added with 389,379 views

Status

  • Digital Utility Expert

Top Members

Shared Link

  • Share
  • Sign in to Vote Like
  • Comment
  • Jan 20, 2021 3:56 pm GMTJan 20, 2021 5:07 pm GMT
  • 630 views

Felder: NEPOOL’s Pathways to the Future Grid Process Project Report

The article linked below contains Dr. Felder's 1/7/2021 assessment of the various pathways considered ny NEPOOL, focused in particular on the following two questions: 1) whether and to what extent pathways support (or help to advance) the clean energy policies of States and 2) whether and to what extent pathways garner efficiency of regional markets?

Read More
Source: nepool.com

Dr. Felder demonstrates a clear understanding of the objectives, and challenges, associated with a future pathway forward for NEPOOL to address State energy goals while simultaneously ensuring a reliable electric system for the region. He identifies four criteria representing critical success factors that must be addressed by a proposal in order to be considered viable:

  1. the achievement of States’ energy objectives
  2. addressing the so-called double capacity payment issue
  3. ensuring sufficient price integrity in the markets (i.e., addressing price suppression)
  4. the increasing need for balancing resources in a future state. Pathways may not procure sufficient amounts and types of balancing resources that the region needs to operate the grid reliably

He analyzed several of the proposed options in detail, with the following conclusions regarding item 4, the need for balancing resources needed for reliability:

  • neither the FCEM nor the ICCM explicitly address the balancing resource issue
  • Net carbon pricing does not explicitly address the balancing resource issue

He accurately points out that both carbon pricing and FCEM/ICCM options fail to adequately address the acquisition of resources needed for system balancing (reliability), which is an absolute necessity for any solution that claims to be a solution for resource adequacy and a replacement for the existing Forward Capacity Market.

I agree with the majority of Dr. Felder's findings and analysis in the linked report, with one exception regarding the following statements.

Two options propose changes/reforms to the FCM: Capacity as a Commodity (Gabel Associates, 2020) and Always on Capacity Exchange(“AOCE”) (Reliable Energy Analytics, 2019). As currently formulated, however, both options have not explicitly made clear how they would help to advance or achieve States’ clean energy objectives, address the double payment/price suppression tradeoff, or ensure sufficient balancing resources. If either of these options are pursued in future pathway discussions, it would be useful to understand how they would specifically help to facilitate the resolution of one or more of these issues.

It's unclear what information Dr. Felder reviewed to reach this conclusion, however I would encourage him to look more closely at the design mechanisms within AOCE that address all of these criteria:

AOCE addresses the need to satisfy State Energy goals as a first priority as indicated in these references:

  • https://github.com/rjb4standards/Presentations/blob/master/Always%20on%20capacity%20exchange%20Conceptual%20Overview-NEPOOL.pptx?raw=true
  • https://energycentral.com/c/ec/aoce-scorecard-achieve-nescoe%E2%80%99s-wholesale-market-design-vision
  • https://energycentral.com/c/ec/achieving-new-england-state-energy-goals-within-aoce-nepool-wholesale-capacity

AOCE addresses the double payment and price suppression issues by providing States with a capacity exchange as an alternative to RFP processes currently used to acquire resources to meet State Energy Goals. Resources needed to satisfy State energy programs can be acquired through AOCE, using a competitive wholesale market approach, eliminating double payments, that occur today. Price suppression is addressed by replacing FCM with a clearing process whereby each grid service is cleared independently resulting in a uniform clearing price for capacity.

  • https://github.com/rjb4standards/Presentations/blob/master/AOCE-AGO-Meeting-20190123.pdf
  • https://energycentral.com/c/ec/aoce-helps-nepool-generators-receive-proper-valuation-and-saves-consumers

AOCE addresses the acquisition of critical grid services offered by resources needed for balancing and to ensure reliability of electric service across New England:

  • https://energycentral.com/c/ec/how-does-aoce-help-isorto%E2%80%99s-acquire-adequate-grid-services-capacity-needed

I welcome the opportunity to address any questions or comments from Dr. Felder, in order to provide a more accurate assessment of the AOCE proposal, and it's ability to satisfy the items cited as concerns in his analysis of AOCE, in time to include an updated analysis of AOCE in his final report.

  • report
  • reliability-&-resiliency
Richard Brooks's picture

Thank Richard for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.

Sign in to Vote Like this post
Follow
More posts from this member
  • NTIA SBOM Proof of Concept for the energy industry
  • NYISO: Road to 2040: Our Interconnection Queue Shows Unprecedented Growth of Clean Energy Investment in NY - NYISO
  • Basic cybersecurity standards must start with procurements, experts say - FedScoop
  • The National Academies Press: The Future of Electric Power in the United States (2021)

Discussions

Spell checking: Press the CTRL or COMMAND key then click on the underlined misspelled word.

Sign in to Participate

No discussions yet. Start a discussion below.

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

Start a Post »                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »

Your access to Member Features is limited.

Sign InApply for membership
  • Share a link
Related Content
'Green hydrogen hub' proposed for the Highlands
Japan harnesses offshore wind to power the future
Open Energy Data Platform For The Future of Energy
One Lesson from the Texas Energy Crisis: We Need a More Flexible Grid

Recent Comments

William Buchan
William commented on ...
Managing Complexity in the Distributed Reality: A Utility Perspective on DERMs
Andy, I enjoyed your article on managing DER and the perspective on DERMS.  Do you think utlities are looking for one packaged DERM solution or...
Jason Price
Jason commented on ...
Managing Complexity in the Distributed Reality: A Utility Perspective on DERMs
In the article you talk about two new waves in digitization of the energy system: blockchain and transactive energy.
Matt Chester
Matt commented on ...
Managing Complexity in the Distributed Reality: A Utility Perspective on DERMs
 annual DER capacity will surpass traditional forms of generation 2:1 in the next decade

Sponsors & Partners

EnergyCentralJobs
Esri
Energy Central
Bentley Systems, Inc.
Clevest
Anterix
S&C Electric Company
Fluix
Owl Cyber Defense
ACI Worldwide
CTC Global
AESP
PLMA (Peak Load Management Alliance)
Guidehouse

Energy Central
Our Mission
Our mission at Energy Central is to help global power industry professionals work better. Our Power Industry Network™ platform is built to help our members connect with each other, share their knowledge & experience and advance their careers in the industry. Membership is open to professionals working at utilities and organizations supporting the industry.

Energy Central

  • Membership
  • Community Standards
  • Participate!
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us

Get Social

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook

Stay Connected

  • Subscribe
  • Follow via RSS
  • Contact Us