This special interest group is for professionals to connect and discuss all types of carbon-free power alternatives, including nuclear, renewable, tidal and more.

Bob Meinetz's picture
Nuclear Power Policy Activist Independent

I am a passionate advocate for the environment and nuclear energy. With the threat of climate change, I’ve embarked on a mission to help overcome the fears of nuclear energy. I’ve been active in...

  • Member since 2018
  • 6,455 items added with 157,576 views
  • Oct 25, 2021
  • 154 views

"STURGIS – It didn’t take Meade County commissioners long at all Tuesday to tell an out-of-state developer they didn’t want a wind farm in eastern Meade County.

Scott Debenham, president of Debenham Energy of San Diego, Calif., had asked to be included on the commission meeting agenda for its Tuesday meeting. Debenham, speaking to the commission via phone, explained that the government is beginning to open Forest Service land for alternative energy development.

He told commissioners he was seeking a letter of support from them for the development of wind and/or solar energy on land managed by the US Forest Service on the Black Hills National Forest in eastern Meade County."

Photo: a ranch in Meade County, South Dakota. Beautiful countryside, but how much more beautiful with 100 125-meter bird grinders spread about the landscape!

Bob Meinetz's picture
Thank Bob for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member
Discussions
Spell checking: Press the CTRL or COMMAND key then click on the underlined misspelled word.
Joe Deely's picture
Joe Deely on Oct 25, 2021

Bob,

 

It's hilarious that you would pick South Dakota as a location to try and post a negative story about wind.  

In reality, South Dakota is probably the state with best wind story over the last three years.

Let's take a look ...

First, let's see what electricity demand is in SD. Here is EIA State electricity profile for SD in 2019 - they haven't done 2020 yet.

 

 

About 13 TWh of demand with generation slightly higher in 2019.

 

Now let's take a look at EIA reported fuel mix over the last few years in SD.

 

 

Wow! Wind generation doubled in 2020. Plus, if you add wind and Hydro you get over 14 TWh of zero carbon generation - enough to meet all of SD demand.

 

How did that happen you say?  Over the last few years Wind capacity has more than tripled in the state. Tripled!

 

In fact, all ten of these wind projects have been added since Nov of 2019.

 

If you look further you'll notice that some of these projects were added late in 2020 and more in 2021.  So, how is wind doing so far this year? Thru Jul 2021 wind generation is up 77% Y-Y in SD !  Wow again!

 

Let's conservatively put wind generation at 8 TWh for the full year 2021 in SD. Throw in 8 TWh of Hydro generation and you far surpass total demand (14Twh) in SD. Maybe they should start adding more solar on to the grid.

 

Keep trying Bob... the more you try and denigrate renewables the better they do.

 

 

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Oct 27, 2021

"In reality, South Dakota is probably the state with best wind story over the last three years."

Sure, if you don't live there. That's the reality, Joe: Not In My Back Yard.

Joe Deely's picture
Joe Deely on Oct 28, 2021

Sure, if you don't live there.

Actually, 87% of South Dakotans don't live in the same county as a wind turbine.

 

Let's take a quick look at some data regarding the 1,300 turbines currently operating across South Dakota's 49M acres.

 

Here are the counties where those turbines were installed -

 

Here are the Top 20 counties by population in SD.

 

What's the crossover Bob?  How many of the the Top 20 counties have a wind turbine within its boundaries? Three.

 

So for most South Dakotans - not really backyard. It's a large empty state. 

 

Next up for SD a few GW of solar. Renewables (Wind Hydro,Solar) will supply 140% of its electricity demand. Another renewables success story.

 

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Oct 29, 2021

"So for most South Dakotans - not really backyard. It's a large empty state. "


You sound like Scott Debenham, Joe, a real Californian. Fill someone else's "large empty state" with your industrial crap.

550,000 raptors (hawks, eagles, and falcons), ducks, and geese are mangled by U.S. wind turbines each year. I suppose a few hundred thousand more won't matter...it's all part of the "renewables success story", right?
 

 

Joe Deely's picture
Joe Deely on Oct 29, 2021

Gotcha Bob - can't dispute the facts so change argument. Standard.

 

Personally, I have no problem with Scott D. trying to sell his wind project into South Dakota. I also have no problem with Meade County commissioners turning him down. 

 

If I was asked where I thought SD should go next with projects for their grid I would recommend solar/storage to balance current Hydro/Wind.

 

With a Wind/Hydro/Solar/Storage grid SD can generate well over 100% of its in-state demand.

 

For you Bob - there is no nuclear - so you will denigrate the other zero carbon sources that are actually working. Good luck with that. Seems to be working well.

 

 

 

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »