WASHINGTON, Sept. 28 -- Rep. Diana DeGette, D-Colorado, issued the following news release and letter on Sept. 27, 2022:
Lawmakers on Capitol Hill are demanding answers today as more than 500,000 Americans in Puerto Rico remain without power more than one week after Hurricane Fiona made landfall there.
U.S. Rep. Diana DeGette (D-CO), chair of the House Energy and Commerce Oversight and Investigations panel, along with Reps. Frank Pallone, Jr. (D-NJ) and Bobby L. Rush (D-IL), sent a letter Tuesday to the head of LUMA Energy, the company responsible for operating Puerto Rico's power grid, to express their deep concern over the island's ongoing power outages and demanded to know what's being done to restore power there immediately.
In writing to LUMA Energy President and CEO Wayne Stensby, the lawmakers said they wanted to know, among other things, "why the company had not adequately prepared the island's energy infrastructure to withstand a Category One hurricane."
They also pointed out that their concerns with the company's ability to develop and maintain the island's power grid started well before Hurricane Fiona hit and that the ongoing outages only "amplify concerns" that LUMA has failed to adequately maintain the island's electrical infrastructure.
Despite being "richly compensated," the lawmakers noted, the company - which became Puerto Rico's sole supplier of electricity in June 2021 - has failed to provide Puerto Ricans with the reliable and affordable energy they deserve.
"Since LUMA assumed control of the grid in 2021, Puerto Ricans have reported recurring power surges that have interfered with critical medical care, disrupted access to education, and destroyed property," the lawmakers wrote. "The collapse of the electric grid in the aftermath of Hurricane Fiona is just the latest example of such failures."
The lawmakers demanded that company officials provide the committee answers to a series of questions regarding the steps LUMA has taken to improve and protect Puerto Rico's power grid since taking control, including:
1. How much funding LUMA has received through its contract with the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority;
2. What reliability benchmarks the company is obliged to achieve, and the progress LUMA has made toward each;
3. What preparations LUMA made to protect Puerto Rico's power grid in advance of Hurricane Fiona;
4. When LUMA anticipates that customers will have their power restored; and
5. What, if anything, LUMA is doing to improve the grid's performance going forward.
The lawmakers requested the information be provided to the committee by Oct. 11, 2022, and that company representatives provide them a briefing on the progress being made to restore power to the island no later than Oct. 14.
* * *
September 27, 2022
To: Mr. Wayne Stensby, President & Chief Executive Officer, LUMA Energy, LLC, 644 Fernandez Juncos Ave., Suite 301, San Juan, PR 00907
Dear Mr. Stensby:
We write with grave concern regarding the island-wide power outage in Puerto Rico following Hurricane Fiona, which left roughly 1.5 million of your customers without electricity./1 In June 2021, your company, LUMA Energy, became Puerto Rico's exclusive electric transmission and distribution operator./2 But ongoing outages and the complete disruption of power following Hurricane Fiona amplify concerns that LUMA has failed to adequately develop and maintain crucial electrical infrastructure in Puerto Rico despite its lucrative 15-year contract.
Our concerns about LUMA predate the current blackout. Since LUMA assumed control of the grid in 2021, Puerto Ricans have reported recurring power surges that have interfered with critical medical care, disrupted access to education, and destroyed property./3 In exchange for this inadequate service, Puerto Ricans spend an increasingly disproportionate share of their income on electricity: the average citizen in mainland United States spends 2.4 percent of their income on electricity whereas Puerto Ricans spend 8 percent of theirs./4
There was never a doubt that rebuilding infrastructure following Hurricane Maria would be a challenge, but LUMA has been richly compensated to meet that challenge. Yet, results are not being delivered to Puerto Ricans, who deserve reliable and affordable energy. The collapse of the electric grid in the aftermath of Hurricane Fiona is just the latest example of such failures.
In order to bring much-needed transparency to LUMA's activities, we request information regarding how LUMA is allocating its contract money and why the company had not adequately prepared the island's energy infrastructure to withstand a Category One hurricane. Please provide responses to the following by October 11, 2022:
1. Describe the amount of funding that your company has received annually through its contract with the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (PREPA). In providing your response, please break out contract revenue both annually and by category, such as annual fees, incentive fees, or any other revenue-generating provisions of the contract.
2. Provide a description of the reliability benchmarks under the contract with PREPA, including your company's progress to date in meeting each of those benchmarks.
3. For each of the seven rate increases that your company has implemented since June 2021, please explain:
a. the rationale for each increase;
b. the amount of increased revenue generated by each increase; and
c. whether and how LUMA has reinvested that revenue in measures to improve electric reliability.
4. Describe any grid resilience measures or other preparation efforts made in advance of Hurricane Fiona and LUMA's present understanding of the efficacy of those efforts.
5. Provide the dates by which you anticipate that:
a. 50 percent of your customers will have power restored;
b. 75 percent of your customers will have power restored; and
c. 100 percent of your customers will have power restored.
6. Summarize any grid resilience technologies currently utilized by LUMA (e.g., energy storage, microgrids, etc.) and any plans to implement additional technologies.
7. Describe any changes that have been made to LUMA's investments and strategy going forward as a result of the grid's performance during and after Hurricane Fiona.
8. Describe any infrastructure investments that LUMA made to facilitate the interconnection of renewable energy to the grid, including rooftop solar maintained by individual customers or communities.
In addition, we request a briefing for Committee staff by October 14, 2022, to receive a detailed update on LUMA's progress in restoring power to Puerto Rican customers and to better understand LUMA's overall performance under its contract and its plans to mitigate harm to Puerto Ricans in future disasters.
We appreciate your urgent attention to this matter. Please contact Will McAuliffe or Tyler O'Connor with the Committee staff at (202) 225-2927 for any questions regarding your response and to schedule a briefing.
Frank Pallone, Jr., Chairman
Bobby L. Rush, Chairman, Subcommittee on Energy
Diana DeGette, Chair, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
* * *
1/ Puerto Rico Power Grid no Match for Fiona; Residents Unsurprised, Reuters (Sept. 20, 2022); Puerto Rico Re-Examines Plan to Fix Power Grid as Fiona Cuts Electricity, Wall Street Journal (Sept. 19, 2022).
2/ Private Company Takes Over Puerto Rico Power Utility Service, Associated Press (June 1, 2021); Puerto Rico Public-Private Partnerships Authority, Puerto Rico Transmission and Distribution System Operation and Maintenance Agreement (June 22, 2020) (https://www.p3.pr.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/executed- consolidated-om-agreement-td.pdf).
3/ 'LUMA, Get Out': Puerto Ricans Clash With Police in Protests Against Power Company, Gizmodo (Sept. 2, 2022).
4/ Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, Latest Puerto Rico Plan For Electric Grid Is a Step In the Wrong
* * *
Original text here: https://degette.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/lawmakers-demand-answers-more-500000-remain-without-power-puerto-rico