Senior decision-makers come together to connect around strategies and business trends affecting utilities.

Post

Utilities Have the Transition Blues — No Way From Here to There

image credit: USPLASH
Llewellyn King's picture
Executive Producer and Host White House Media, LLC

Llewellyn King is the creator, executive producer and host of “White House Chronicle,” a weekly news and public affairs program, airing nationwide on PBS and public, educational and government...

  • Member since 2018
  • 86 items added with 84,743 views
  • Jan 9, 2023
  • 241 views

A perfect storm is gathering over the electric utility industry in the United States. It may break this year, next year or the year after, but break it will.

That is the consensus from utility executives I have been talking to over the past month. Several issues together amount to a clear danger of widespread blackouts and brownouts in the coming years. They come under the rubric of “transition.”

There are, in fact, two transitions stretching the electric utility industry. One is the climate imperative to turn from fossil fuels, primarily coal and natural gas with a smidgeon of oil, to renewables, almost totally wind and solar.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration reckons that electricity from solar and wind will rise this year from 24 percent to 26 percent and that natural gas, the workhorse of the generation mix, will fall from 38 percent to 36 percent. The balance is dwindling coal use at 19 percent, and nuclear, hydro and geothermal generation making up the rest.

That leaves a significant need for new renewable generation: That is the first transition. It isn’t going as fast as the environmental lobby, or the Biden administration, would like, nor even as fast as the utilities would like. It has been substantially crimped by the supply chain tangle.

The American Public Power Association and the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association have been vocal about the shortage of pole transformers. The supply has dried up. Without transformers, new hookups are impossible and old ones are threatened if the transformers fail. The waiting list for something as simple as a bucket truck is three years.

Recent legislation has poured money at an unprecedented rate into the development of renewables, but none of it will help in the short term. It is a case of trying to force more of something into a bladder that is expanding too slowly and that can’t expand faster because of multiple restraints. A utility executive told me that the money is, if anything, making matters worse.

One of the things most concerning to the utilities is the fate of natural gas, both for its availability and price. Gas remains the principal go-to fuel for utilities. Many regard gas as a storage system even if they aren’t burning it to generate power daily.

Gas is special because it is relatively clean, it can be stored, and it can be installed in a short time at many locations. It doesn’t require trains, as does coal, and it works in any weather if the plants have been properly weatherized. Also, gas is very efficient so more of it can be transformed into electricity through so-called combined-cycle plants. It beats coal and nuclear hands down on the simplicity of the infrastructure it needs. Its efficiency is rated at about 64 percent versus 32 percent, or thereabouts, for coal.

Many utility executives believe gas should be the primary way we store energy. They advocate maintaining a robust gas infrastructure so that it can come online quickly when needed and can run for as long as needed, unlike batteries.

But national gas policy is confusing. We want gas to be sent to Europe but not piped to New England, which may have an electricity deficit this winter, if not the next.

The second transition, working in tandem with the first, is electrification.

The United States is already headed toward a totally electrified transportation system, but heavy industry, like steel and cement, is also switching to electricity. Demand is showing the first signs of explosive growth. By 2050, demand will have more than doubled, according to many surveys.

While that alone is destabilizing, there is a wild card: the new unpredictable weather behavior.

This winter so far, we have had floods in California, freezing in Texas, tornadoes in the Midwest, and record snowfall in Buffalo. Add this to the other variables in electricity delivery, and you have a very troubling picture with such things as attacks on substations, cyberattacks and that pesky supply chain.

My advice: Keep spare batteries handy and a good supply of canned food. If you are sitting in the dark, you don’t want to be hungry.

Discussions
Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Jan 9, 2023

Hopefully the 'mini' events and scares we've had thus far will motivate utility and political leaders to take action without having to wait for the 'big one' to really convince them on the drastic actions that are needed. 

Ed Reid's picture
Ed Reid on Jan 16, 2023

Matt, Drastic actions by utilities require utility commission approval. Drastic actions require major investments, which result in rate increases. Utility commissions resist rate increases and thus resist drastic actions.

The federal government is feeding the renewables frenzy and pushing electrification, while also demanding shutdown of coal (2030) and gas (2035) generation. Natural gas cannot provide "storage" if there is no gas; and, batteries cannot provide storage if the don't exist or are unaffordable.

Michael Keller's picture
Michael Keller on Jan 16, 2023

Setting aside the “climate emergency” propaganda, I suspect pragmatic considerations are going to cause the “transition” to grind to a halt.

At the most fundamental level, the “green mafia” is going to run out of other peoples money.

The claimed “needed” new transmission lines will run into increasingly fierce, protracted opposition. Ditto for new renewable energy megastructure projects, particularly offshore wind.

The basic shortcomings of electric vehicles (e.g. range, ability to re-charge, availability of energy to recharge) will become more apparent, in spite of the government’s attempt to bribe Americans to embrace the technology.

Bottom line, reality will ultimately overtake those pushing an I’ll-advised hysterical agenda just to line their own pockets. Unfortunately, the economic carnage created by this corruption will become increasingly severe before the pendulum inevitably swings back to a more balanced position.

Utilities would do well to maintain a balanced strategic view and avoid the temptation to jump on the transitory mirage of an all-electric economy.

 

Peter Farley's picture
Peter Farley on Jan 17, 2023

Most of the claims of the need for more transmission and storage are over-stated. Germany has far lower proportion of its electricity from hydro and other storage than the US and yet it is already running at 50% renewables.

South Australia is running at 70% renewables with no hydro or nuclear and 8 minutes of battery storage. 

Small batteries (20%of peak power three hours storage) at both ends of a transmission line to an existing wind or solar province can increase its annual throughput 30-50%.

Then are simple demand changes like making ice for cool stores before midday, heating water and doing municipal water transfer during the day, to reduce nighttime demand by 10-15%

Then of course there is the big one, energy efficiency. If the US reduced its energy consumption to only 20% more per $ of GDP than the EU, it already generates enough electricity to electrify 90% of its entire ground transport fleet plus supply all existing electrical demand.  

Ed Reid's picture
Ed Reid on Jan 17, 2023

Averages are interesting, but demand frequently exceeds the averages.

Llewellyn King's picture
Thank Llewellyn for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »