This group brings together those who are interested in topics around oil and gas exploration, drilling, refining, and processing.


The Great Commodity Crisis

image credit: Shutterstock
Gerard Reid's picture
Leader Alexa Capital

Gerard Reid is is focused on assisting people and organizations in the energy and mobility areas who are struggling to understand and come to terms with unpredictable and rapid change going on...

  • Member since 2019
  • 152 items added with 131,664 views
  • Mar 22, 2022

We live in dangerous times, no more so if you are in Ukraine today. But these are also dangerous times for the wider world.  I was thus not surprised some days ago when the German Economics and Energy Minister, Robert Harbeck, warned that ‘Germany’s people may face mass unemployment and poverty if there was an immediate boycott of Russian gas and oil.’ There was much criticism of his comments as there are calls across the world for a ban on Russian fossil fuel imports but note that Europe is currently paying circa $1bn per day to Russia for those fuels.  However, we need to be careful in dangerous times as unforeseen things can happen and it is critical to ensure financial stability, whatever happens.

The sanctions against Russia are the hardest we have seen against any country to date and in particular the decision to freeze $600bn of Russian foreign reserves is a first, which will have huge consequences in the long-term. In the short term, a funding crisis is unfolding for anyone involved in the commodities that Russia produces. Russia is the largest producer and exporter of commodities in the world, starting with oil and gas representing 10% and 24% of global production respectively. Then add in 30% of sunflower oil exports, 16% of global wheat exports and 13% of barley exports. In the global metals sector, Russia accounts for 30% of nickel exports, 24% of palladium, 16% of platinum, 10% of aluminum and 5% of steel. And if one includes the Ukraine the numbers are even higher. 

We are already seeing massive stress and volatility in all these markets. The most notable is nickel where nickel prices rocketed up by 250% in less than two days obliging the London Metals Exchange to close the exchange, cancelling $4bn in trades and when it did finally reopen the exchange’s trading system it malfunctioned repeatedly. Good luck to you if you have not already secured nickel for stainless steel production or lithium-ion batteries this year.

In energy, particularly in Europe, we are already seeing enormous stress thanks to all-time highs in gas prices which are in turn causing volatility and stress in power markets. Already, we have seen the German development bank, the KFW give emergency loans to three energy companies: Leag, VNG and Uniper, and in the UK over thirty retail utilities have gone bankrupt over the last 6 months. And there is more to come.

The fact is that the sanctions are taking Russian commodities out of the market (incl. oil and coal despite them not being sanctioned) which, together with inadequate stock inventories means that there is not enough supply globally which is pushing energy prices up for everyone. This means the companies need to borrow more money to buy, move and sell these commodities. Secondly, market participants need to lock in prices for future deliveries. They do so by selling a financial derivative such as a future. On the other side, buyers often buy futures to lock in their price. These hedging mechanisms require cash guarantees to be paid so that if one side cannot deliver on their commitments, the other side is not financially disadvantaged. These so called ‘margin calls’ are usually funded by credit lines from banks but in the current extremely volatile markets, banks are shying away from this type of business. To fill that gap, the German KFW had to jump in to prevent what otherwise could have been the bankruptcy of a system relevant energy company.

Going forward, we need governments to allow the European Central Bank, the Bank of England, and the US Federal Reserve to step in to ensure the necessary liquidity is available for trades to happen. The bottom line is that global trading markets were not designed to withstands shocks like this. The good news is that this liquidity is a loan so when the commodity is delivered that loan can be repaid with interest on top. The difficulty is that providing liquidity to so many market players is against the interests of Europe and the US who are both driving for sanctions. It is also difficult because you do not want to be in the business of bailing out ‘free riders’ and speculators.

To further complicate the situation, commodity price rises must be passed onto consumers across the world in the form of higher heating bills at the same time they are facing rising bread prices. In addition, supply shortages of raw materials cause production to falter and place stresses on businesses that cannot make payments or secure resources at necessary prices which exacerbates the situation. Recession is the outcome. Finally, what the German Economics and Energy Minister Robert Harbeck should have warned about is that ‘People across the world may face mass unemployment and poverty if there is not a quick end to the Ukrainian crisis.’  Let us hope for a peaceful outcome soon as we are not in a good situation otherwise.




Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Mar 22, 2022

Finally, what the German Economics and Energy Minister Robert Harbeck should have warned about is that ‘People across the world may face mass unemployment and poverty if there is not a quick end to the Ukrainian crisis.’  

We always knew how interconnected the global trade markets were, but this really does serve as an eye-opener on the widespread impacts that can happen amid interruption to supplies. Hopefully that reality for the oil and gas markets today can be lessons for future commodities (lithium and cobalt for batteries, anyone?) to better prepare and ensure any single actor has moderated influence and power. 

Julian Silk's picture
Julian Silk on Mar 22, 2022

I hate to disagree with Matt Chester and Gerard Reid on this. Matt Chester in particular is an extremely nice guy. So I hope all concerned will just take this as a difference of opinion and not being derogatory in any way. But the onset of the Cold War caused great hardship for Europe for a few years, but eventually this was overcome by the Marshall Plan and by the efforts of the Europeans. The problems with climate and the invasion will be similarly overcome, though it may take time, and at least I may not live to see the solution.

Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Mar 22, 2022

Difference of opinions are always welcome and encouraged, Julian! I appreciate your perspective, and I hope you are right. 

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Mar 22, 2022

"I was thus not surprised some days ago when the German Economics and Energy Minister, Robert Harbeck, warned that ‘Germany’s people may face mass unemployment and poverty if there was an immediate boycott of Russian gas and oil.’"

Neither was I, Gerard, nor will I be surprised when Harbeck changes his mind - again - and extends the lives of three German nuclear plants scheduled for closure in December.

Citizens of France also faced mass unemployment and starvation when the OPEC oil embargo threatened to shutter their country's oil-fired power plants in 1973. Prime Minister Pierre Messmer, however, recognized the threat energy dependence presented, and launched the Messmer Plan - a goal of repowering France with 100% nuclear electricity. Today, thanks to Messmer's vision and determination, France has the cleanest and most affordable electricity in the EU.

Despite this clear example in history, I suspect Germans will have to learn the hard way of the limitations of policy based in ideology. But I shouldn't be surprised about that either - it wouldn't be the first time.

Vladimir Vinogradov's picture
Vladimir Vinogradov on Mar 29, 2022

Hello Gerard. Russia's President Vladimir Putin March 23 ordered Gazprom to sell gas to Europe in rubles and threatened extending the measure to other exports, in a move that has sent prices surging. See here

Russia is finding ways to bypass sanctions on its oil supplies and customers are "happy to buy" its discounted crude. See here

Russia will cope with this crisis. If this crisis ends quickly, it will be better for everyone.

Julian Silk's picture
Julian Silk on Mar 29, 2022

Dear Gerard and Vladimir and others,

Things may well be different this time.  This is the first armed invasion in a European country (not Afghanistan) since WWII, unless you want to count the 2014 invasion, which was less serious.  The European countries won't be able to let bygones be bygones, because the root causes have not been resolved.


Gerard Reid's picture
Thank Gerard for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »