Part of Grid Network »

The Grid Professionals Group covers electric current from its transmission step down to each customer's home. 

WARNING: SIGN-IN

You need to be a member of Energy Central to access some features and content. Please or register to continue.

Post

Final Findings on California's Outages Highlight Need for Storage

image credit: Illustration 160098969 ©

  • Jan 21, 2021 4:40 pm GMT
  • 207 views

It’s finally time to stop all the speculation. After much anticipation, The California Independent System Operator (CAISO), California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and California Energy Commission (CEC) released their comprehensive root cause analysis last week of the underlying causes behind summer 2020’s rolling outages. The final findings are not all that surprising. Like the preliminary reports suggested, and many commentators already assumed, a nasty combination of a historic heatwave, resource planning issues, and some myopic market practices left the Golden State fighting for air. 

This report will disappoint both the natural gas fanboys who’ve held up California’s woes as proof that renewables can’t work, and the quixotic renewable advocates who’ve claimed the blame lay solely with outdated regulation and demand response programs. 

California was a clean energy trendsetter, becoming one of the first states to adopt a plan for going carbon neutral some time ago. As it stands now, the state has the stated goal of being carbon-free by 2045 and boasts 29.2 GW solar and nearly 6 GW of wind generation. 

To put it simply, CAISO would not have failed the way they did had they had access to a more traditional energy portfolio. That being said, more intelligent planning targets would have probably mitigated most of the power outages we saw. The market had not scheduled enough demand and, making matters worse, day-ahead rules made it all but impossible to notice the mistake. 

So, what has to change to make sure this doesn’t happen again? Rule changes, first of all, and they’re already underway. The CPUC has opened an emergency reliability rulemaking to ensure greater resource procurement before summer 2021. CAISO is also recommending that the commission raise resource adequacy targets for peak hours.

The grid itself will also need to look radically different if California hopes to meet clean energy goals without sinking to Venezuela-like reliability levels. Namely, the state needs to invest heavily in storage and make sure the projects get on line right away. The CPUC and CAISO have recognized this and have already taken steps in the right direction. In addition to acknowledging the need for more batteries, the agencies have promised to do everything in their power to see planned projects are completed on time. 

However, the state will most likely need many more batteries than those that have been planned. The good news is batteries are going to be really cheap this decade. According to recent statements coming out of the Electric Power Research Institute, it’s possible that costs for battery packs will drop from about $120-200/kWh to $80kWh by 2030. That’s encouraging. 

California’s grid is sure to look dramatically different by the end of this decade. And if it doesn’t, we can expect to see even greater emigration from the state. That being said, even if all the ideal storage goals aren’t met exactly on time, it’s possible the state won’t see another such heatwave for sometime. Fingers crossed.

 

Henry Craver's picture

Thank Henry for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.

Discussions

Spell checking: Press the CTRL or COMMAND key then click on the underlined misspelled word.
Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Jan 21, 2021

"Namely, the state needs to invest heavily in storage and make sure the projects get on line right away."

Henry, "investing heavily in storage", to power an electrical grid, would be a joke if so many people weren't taking it seriously. There isn't a single grid in the world powered by renewables + batteries, nor will there ever be. For many, many reasons:

  1. At today's prices, running California for a single cloudy, calm day would cost batteries costing $600 billion - twice California's entire annual budget. A week's batteries would cost $4.2 trillion. They will never, ever be cheap enough.
  2. They would need to be replaced every 7-10 years.
  3. When rolling blackouts struck California's grid in August, all the batteries in the state were capable of generating two-tenths of one percent of current electrical demand - for a period of ten minutes (ironically, they were needed just before noon, when the sun was supposed to be providing electricity).
  4. Grid batteries in California are now being charged by one of two sources: 1) the direct output of a gas plant, or 2) a grid mix. In both cases they increase carbon emissions (we're better off keeping gas plants online). If you thought they were being charged by exclusively renewable energy, think again.
  5. Grid batteries are currently being used not for power, but for ancillary services - fixing voltage and frequency instability introduced by solar and wind. Get rid of solar and wind, and we don't need batteries. A win-win.

Ask an electrical engineer, ask a physicist: powering an electrical grid with batteries is one of the stupidest energy ideas ever to gain traction at a state level, much less a national one. It's being promoted by both natural gas fanboys and quixotic renewables advocates to shut down nuclear plants - and in California, Diablo Canyon Power Plant is target #1.

onedit: double consumption, if we're going to electrify transportation and space heating, and the price tag becomes $1.2 trillion/day. Batteries + renewables + gas is a recipe for climate and economic disaster.

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »