Mon, Jul 22

Winds of Change

 

As many are aware, the U.S. Supreme Court recently issued a number of decisions that will have far ranging repercussions in regulatory arenas. In particular, a sea change is very likely to sweep through regulatory agencies employing complex regulations and guidance documents that involve highly technical and scientific areas, with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) a prime example.

 In summary, the earlier approach (broadly, the Chevron doctrine) of courts deferring to regulatory agency interpretation of statutes has been overturned, as has been the six month limitation for mounting legal challenges.

By way of background, the general process for regulating nuclear power is illustrated. Historically, the NRC employs guidance documents to amplify NRC preferences involving the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR).

Statutes explicitly require NRC/Industry collaboration to support an efficient licensing process and explicitly require the use of risk informed approaches. The later means licensing efforts must be commiserate with the public’s hazardous radiation risk.

On a near term basis, challenges will emerge to activities involving industry codes/standards and the use of guidance documents.

There is a long history of using industry codes/standards in the design, manufacture, construction and operation of nuclear power plants. These consensus documents have been developed by industry experts, including NRC Staff, and have evolved in parallel with technology innovations. The use of industry codes/standards is explicitly supported by law.

NRC guidance documents labor under the presumption that:  (1) industry codes/standards must be NRC endorsed, (2) the applicant must justify the use of unendorsed codes/standards, and (3) guidance can override industry codes and standards. There is no statutory support for such positions, particularly when considering the historically routine use of legions of unendorsed codes/standards. Further, the NRC has been explicitly directed by statute to collaborate with industry on code/standard development.

Complications also lie with regulations and guidance activities uncoupled from statutory risk informed mandates.

Meaningful assessments of public radiation hazards are not possible absent the applicant’s risk-informed, defense-in-depth based demonstration of compliance with statutes, key elements of the Code of Federal Regulations, and applicant embraced governing industry codes/standards.

As periodically stated by NRC Staff, guidance documents identify designs acceptable to the NRC Staff.  Issues arise when applicants decline to conform to staff preferences. Staff concerns must be tied to specific risk informed elements of statute grounded regulations, as opposed to staff desires. In effect, guidance documents are used to surreptitiously impose backdoor requirements. Such a path leads to immense workloads for all parties. There is no statutory support for such an approach, with the recent Supreme Court decisions upending any notion that legal opposition to such practices cannot be mounted.

  To be clear, there is no statutory support for guidance documents regulating nuclear energy.

 Applicants have long labored under the heavy financial burden of intricate NRC regulations and the immense proliferation of guidance documents. That financial millstone is no longer immune from challenges.

   The NRC would do well to re-assess the use of complex regulations, particularly with respect to the proposed 10CFR53 for advanced reactors. The use of guidance documents should be seriously re-examined.

Litigation generally does not serve our collective best interests. However, the historical NRC approach imposes massive and unnecessary costs. Absence reform, deployment of cost-effective and safe nuclear power is not realistic, with the nation’s need for energy independence threatened.

Michael F. Keller,      Overland Park, Kansas    President

                  

A small U.S. business of the State of Kansas developing patented advanced reactor approaches.

 

Â