In partnership with PLMA, this group is for practitioners from energy utilities, solution providers, and trade allies to share load management expertise and explore innovative approaches to program delivery, pricing constructs, and technology adoption.


A path for FERC to settle tensions in Capacity Markets; look to NAESB OASIS as the model

image credit: Photo by Viviana Rishe on Unsplash
Richard Brooks's picture
Co-Founder and Lead Software Engineer Reliable Energy Analytics LLC

Dick Brooks is the inventor of patent 11,374,961: METHODS FOR VERIFICATION OF SOFTWARE OBJECT AUTHENTICITY AND INTEGRITY and the Software Assurance Guardian™ (SAG ™) Point Man™ (SAG-PM™) software...

  • Member since 2018
  • 1,532 items added with 670,014 views
  • Feb 18, 2019

ISO New England, in its filing to allow State sponsored resources access to capacity markets identified an issue in which energy consumers “pay twice” for capacity when States sponsor generating resources outside of wholesale capacity markets, stating:

Another concern, ISO-NE states, is that the MOPR may cause consumers to “pay twice” for the same capacity—i.e., pay once for capacity procured in the FCM to serve their demand, and pay a second time for the additional capacity obtained through out-of-market contracts with state-supported resources.”

A proposal under development for potential standardization by NAESB, called the “Always on Capacity Exchange” eliminates this pay twice issue by improving the way capacity is secured, using a market based mechanism.

AOCE uses a bid/ask market mechanism in which capacity/energy buyers submit their bids to secure future capacity, by specifying the type of resource they wish to acquire future energy from. An AOCE bid contains requirements such as fuel type (Solar/Wind), emissions outputs allowed, pollutants allowed and the location where the future energy must be delivered to, along with other bid parameters. This would enable Green energy buyers, Investors and traders the opportunity to secure the type of energy they desire from owners of resources that match the buyers bid requirements by placing offers which culminate in a “Capacity Commitment” between bid/offer - buyer/seller.

Two critical success factors make AOCE a solution to the “pay twice” problem:

  1. Capacity Commitment Owners (buyers in the transaction) are incented to acquire capacity in AOCE by receiving the full value of their capacity commitment investment plus an uplift, i.e. 10% for taking on this risk, called the capacity payment. This payment is issued when an ISO issues a Capacity Supply Obligation (CSO) to the offering resources in a capacity commitment agreement when securing capacity to meet State energy targets as a top priority in AOCE.
  2. States no longer need to issue RFP’s to secure green resources, AOCE is the place for bids/offers to clear. However, States must send clear signals to the AOCE market of their energy targets, which dictates the priority order that an ISO must issue CSO’s, resulting in capacity payments being made to capacity commitment owners (investors/buyers), which includes the uplift (profit) guarantee. States do not need to pay for capacity resources using RFP’s, as they do today, they only need to tell the AOCE market what those energy targets are, setting priority status for those commitments that are sure to receive a CSO from the ISO, resulting in payments to the capacity commitment owners.

FERC is being called upon to find a solution to the capacity markets crisis that is occurring across Wholesale Capacity Markets today. FERC staff may wish to consider past successes to managing Transmission Capacity, a NAESB standard known as OASIS, which has successfully and quietly served the Energy Community for over the past 10 years. FERC may wish to consider the success of the OASIS regulation, which was created from the NAESB standards development process, when looking for a forum to produce an industry solution for Capacity Markets. It’s tough to argue against success.

David Darnell's picture
David Darnell on Feb 18, 2019

As a board member of NAESB, I am very interested in particpating in standards development in this area. Keep posting information like this ... it is excellent.


Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Feb 18, 2019

Another concern, ISO-NE states, is that the MOPR may cause consumers to “pay twice” for the same capacity—i.e., pay once for capacity procured in the FCM to serve their demand, and pay a second time for the additional capacity obtained through out-of-market contracts with state-supported resources.”

Déja vu, Richard? Seems we had this same discussion a couple of weeks ago. If it was the result of your input, congratulations - I hope you're credited for it.

Not sure if your success with OASIS is transferable to capacity markets, however. Transmission stays in place for a long, long time, and I get the feeling trying to make intermittent renewable energy reliable, years in the future, will continue to be a fraught exercise. But my understanding of the specifics of OASIS is limited.

I did come across a standard requiring HTTP users to have either Internet Explorer or Netscape Navigator for their browser - maybe that one needs to be updated.

Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Feb 18, 2019

Great stuff as always, Richard. I'm with David here-- please keep this quality content coming as you stay on top of the issue!

Richard Brooks's picture
Thank Richard for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »