How District Energy Can Support the Transition from Empty Offices to Thriving Laboratories
- Dec 23, 2021 5:09 pm GMT
Office Space May Be Cooling Down, but Lab Space Is Heating Up
The COVID-19 pandemic has had a seismic impact on professional office work environments. Before the pandemic, most workplaces were strictly in-office, but now, the majority have shifted to work from home or a hybrid formula. This transition seems to be sticking, which means many office buildings in urban centers are now standing empty.
One type of work that cannot shift to a ‘work from home’ or hybrid model is laboratory research. Lab technicians require specific equipment and ideal environments that are only available in a physical lab. While the demand for office space has plummeted, the need for lab space is higher than ever. As a result, building owners and developers are converting empty offices into labs at an accelerating rate.
Lab space conversions are increasingly popular in areas experiencing notable life science booms, like Boston, Cambridge, Philadelphia, San Francisco, and San Diego. From 2009 to the end of 2019, the amount of lab space in the U.S. grew from 17 million to 29 million square feet. Even smaller cities like New Haven are “desperate” for more lab space because of a huge influx of life science enterprises on the scene. Boston is expected to complete construction for 2 to 3 million sq. ft. of new lab space by 2024. Lab space vacancy in Boston is currently at a mere 4.5%, versus overall office space vacancy, which is as high as 23%. Rents for lab space in the Boston area price at over $100 per sq. ft., making conversions extremely profitable. Furthermore, lab leases are generally 10 to 15 years long, giving landlords assurance that the conversion investments are worth it.
Lab Space Has Several Unique Requirements for Building Owners to Consider
Labs require a whole host of structural and service considerations. Efficient, effective laboratories require appropriate ceiling heights for duct work and equipment, enhanced airflow for the safety of technicians, and viable interior wall and ceiling space for increased mechanical and utility requirements. Developers must also keep in mind that different building codes and zoning requirements may apply, as compared to general office space. Perhaps most importantly, labs require high-quality and high-volume, reliable, 24/7 energy to provide power, cooling, heating, humidification and sterilization to ensure uninterrupted research, sanitized laboratory equipment and tools, and preservation of delicate procedures.
Evaluating Energy Options
District energy is one option to meet the unique requirements of lab space. Life science companies need huge volumes of high-quality, reliable thermal energy to support their critical operations, including specific ventilation, space temperature, humidity requirements, and the sterilization of laboratory tools and equipment. Without the burden of onsite combustion or maintaining chillers or boilers, district energy is a safer option than onsite infrastructure and also requires way less maintenance expense. District steam energy has many advantages:
- For sterilization and humidification, the CDC recommends steam sanitation over conventional sanitation methods.
- District energy is more resilient and reliable even in the face of climate events.
- District energy allows the upper limits of heating to be adjusted, which is necessary for the specific conditions labs require.
- A building can connect just a few floors to district energy if they only want to convert some floors to lab space.
- District energy is a greener option, and many cities have aggressive carbon emissions savings targets.
- This energy solution also frees up valuable floor space, which allows life science companies to focus and leverage valuable square feet for their core operations.
Microgrids and Distributed Generation
A microgrid is an energy grid that typically provides power and thermal energy to a campus or group of buildings in close proximity to each other. In some cases, it makes sense for a research campus to develop an onsite independent energy solution to meet their critical energy needs. Microgrids can even store energy and use renewables. An independent energy developer with finance, engineering, and construction management expertise can develop a custom distributed energy solution, from planning to implementation.
Alternatively, microgrids can also be integrated into district systems to provide more energy resilience and reliability. Labs have extremely high thermal energy and power needs, making a microgrid solution (which provides both) a feasible and practical solution.
Pairing onsite boilers and chillers for thermal energy and engaging a traditional power utility for electricity is often the first option that occurs to many commercial companies and building owners. However, onsite chillers and boilers require substantial upfront capital and ongoing maintenance costs. They take up space in the building, and with boilers risk providing insufficient steam pressure and poor steam quality. Labs require constant airflow in order to maintain a sterile environment – they need approximately five times more air changes than typical office buildings, which is why they tend to put more strain on the HVAC equipment to heat and cool all the fresh air being brought in. More air changes and ventilation requirements put enormous pressure on boilers, especially in the winter, as it decreases the life of boilers, increases fuel costs, and means more repairs and maintenance. Not only does district energy or high-pressure steam from a microgrid provide humidification control, hot water, and heat, but it also allows for the sterilization of equipment. More sustainable energy solutions can cost less from a lifecycle perspective and are often more valuable in the long run.
As office spaces turn into labs, an important component that life science companies must keep in mind are the carbon goals of the cities in which they operate. Many cities have aggressive carbon reduction goals that must be taken into account when planning new commercial and industrial spaces.
Furthermore, many life science companies have goals for greening their own operations, sometimes above and beyond city and/or state guidelines. To attract life science companies and stay current with environmental policies, buildings must not only provide a reliable and cost-effective energy solution, but also one that can adapt to increasingly more stringent sustainability requirements. This is a tricky matter when it comes to onsite energy generation, as any equipment would likely have to be expensively retrofitted in the future to meet greening initiatives. Any energy plan must ensure that both life science tenants will have the HVAC, environmental and space conditions and capacities they need, and also that the building will continue to get greener over time – keeping up with corporate and government sustainability objectives well into the future.