This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.


Who Will Serve the World's Missing Middle?


Diesel generators are the world’s most ubiquitous distributed energy technology – they’re also ripe for displacement.

Around the world a growing number of distributed clean energy technology start-ups have aimed their sights at ending energy poverty by serving a vast untapped market – the 1.2 billion un-electrified people around the world. Their efforts begin by getting people on the first rungs of the energy ladder as quickly and cheaply as possible with pico solar devices that power basic entry level services like lighting and mobile phone charging. Over time they will, in theory, move these populations up the ladder by providing them with ever expanding levels of service. Whether ultimately connected to stand alone home systems with storage, mini-grids or even grid extensions (if or when they arrive) there is only one direction to head – up.

Up the ladder they go

In many ways we see concrete examples of the ladder at work. Several of the beyond the grid (also known as off-grid) industry’s leading companies began by meeting their customers where they were – wasting relatively enormous sums of money on heavily polluting and inefficient lighting powered by kerosene. They displaced this expensive fuel by serving their customers with a combination of the world’s most sophisticated clean energy technologies – solar PV, LED lighting, and Li-Ion Batteries. We now regularly see and hear of companies that started at low rungs of the ladder expanding their product lines to help them shift from selling things their customers need (lights, mobile phone charging) to things they want (TVs).

At the other end of the ladder, many nations have made tremendous progress connecting populations to the centralized grid – the very top of the ladder. Perhaps the best example is China which has connected 1.3 billion people to a centralized grid thanks to its economic transformation. The beauty of a centralized grid is that once connected you can power whatever you want from day one – you get the kitchen sink. However, for a variety of reasons including the cost of serving low population densities in rural areas and poor economic and political governance the progress of expanding the centralized grid has been uneven for many of the world’s poorest countries. Worse in sub Saharan Africa population growth threatens to stall or even reverse the progress.

Chutes and Ladders?

But while both camps – grid extenders, and those operating beyond the grid – relentlessly focus on moving populations up the ladder a quiet crisis has conspired to thwart their efforts. That’s because we have all assumed that once a population gets a grid connection the job is done. 24/7 power for an endlessly growing array of devices and demands. The reality is however much starker.

Some have estimated a population roughly the same size as the purely off-grid world suffer from chronic and prolonged blackouts. These are the ‘under-electrified.’ The regular blackouts they experience don’t just affect household energy demand, they reverberate throughout the economy as industry and manufacturing can be shut down for hours at a time – an enormous cost for poor economies where people get by on dollars a day.

The Missing Middle

That creates a perverse situation where poorly functioning grids send people the opposite direction we are all headed – down the energy ladder. When they do, they force people and enterprises to rely on the world’s most ubiquitous distributed energy technology – the diesel generator (diesel gen set). Where these two flows of people meet is a vast poorly served market ripe for intervention. It’s the missing middle.

IRENA estimates the market at 400 GW
of installed diesel gen sets globally. A market that Navigant sees growing from 62 GW of annual sales to 103 GW in the next ten years coupled with $538 billion in revenue all driven by poorly functioning grids in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia. With some countries like Nigeria seeing capacity factors as high as 60% the diesel bill for backing up poorly performing grids is big. By comparison, the beyond the grid market, is dominated by roughly $27 billion in annual kerosene consumption. Despite their differences the same economic principle holds – people are paying through the nose for expensive, polluting fuels that dirt cheap solar can displace.

Top down or Bottom up?

Eliminating energy poverty is a noble goal but there are a number of important reasons to tackle the missing middle.The first and most important is that these are also energy poor citizens whose economic productivity as well as potential outcome is stifled by a lack of power. At the same time thanks to its sheer size the market is bigger (though not more carbon intensive) than the US coal fleet which makes it a potential opportunity for driving carbon reductions. Last, and most important from a business standpoint, this market has one big upside – the population has had a taste of electricity and now values it so much they’re willing, and able, to pay large amounts to keep the lights on.

That’s why a race to serve the middle may be coming. On one side beyond the grid solar firms who began at the base of the ladder are moving up as the populations they serve expand their demand for energy services. On the other, large energy firms operating in utility scale markets are developing product offerings to move down the ladder. Firms like Gamesa for example now offer a hybrid solar, diesel, and storage product aimed at diesel displacement.

The strategic question now is who best understands the missing middle? It’s a population that has largely been ignored because it’s assumed that centralized grids function. But where they don’t an enormous population has emerged that has proven distributed generation can flourish in emerging markets. For those operating in the shadow of dysfunctional grids the direction of travel is clear – it’s time to move from kerosene killers to diesel displacers. Because the pot of gold may not be at the end of the energy ladder – it’s in the middle.

Original Post


Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on May 26, 2016

Justin, replacing kerosene with “natural gas” (methane) is analogous to replacing coal with methane in developed countries. Unfortunately, eager renewables advocates fail to recognize two fatal flaws with the movement to disributed energy:

1) Renewables will never eliminate dependence on methane, guaranteeing an income stream for fossil fuel companies decades into the future and effectively sealing the fate of climate.

2) By making generation technology cleaner, utilities are capable of improving the emissions of millions of customers simultaneously. Once generation is distributed, emissions are “locked in” to not the cleanest but the cheapest form of generation.

Have distributed generation advocates figured out a way to keep from distributing their fossil fuel emissions? I didn’t think so. Until they do, the movement represents a trend which is exhorbitantly wasteful and exhorbitantly selfish.

Engineer- Poet's picture
Engineer- Poet on May 26, 2016

people are paying through the nose for expensive, polluting fuels that dirt cheap solar can displace.

Displace, but not replace.

Firms like Gamesa for example now offer a hybrid solar, diesel, and storage product aimed at diesel displacement.

This shows all the signs of a lack of system-level analysis.  I’ll bet that there’s a great deal of e.g. gobar-gas potential in these areas, but refrigeration is still reliant on electric-powered compression rather than heat-driven absorption chillers.  Flat-plate collectors can power absorption systems at a CoP on the order of 0.5, competitive with PV+compression at a fraction of the price; gobar gas would supply backup.  Most hardware could probably be domestically sourced in most countries.

Eventually it comes down to applications where there is no economic substitute for electricity, such as lighting and powering motors and electronics.  This is a subset of the broader suite of needs, which ought to be considered on their own merits.

Justin Guay's picture

Thank Justin for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »