This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.


Trending Topics: Four Reasons Why 2016 is the Year of the Wholesale Power Market

America's Power Plan's picture
Energy Innovation
  • Member since 2018
  • 33 items added with 22,805 views
  • Feb 3, 2016

power and electricity

A version of this article was originally published on January 27, 2016 on Greentech Media.

By Sonia Aggarwal

Electricity from competitive wholesale power markets keeps the lights on for two-thirds of all Americans, but pressure is mounting to reform markets to match today’s energy system, and things may be about to change – for the better.

Wholesale power markets evolved in a world where dispatchable, central-station power plants slavishly followed demand; where the environmental costs of producing, delivering, and burning fossil fuels were largely ignored; and where utilities measured their fortunes by how many kilowatt-hours of electricity they delivered to end-use customers. That world is rapidly disappearing due to emerging technologies, evolving consumer preferences, and the need to reduce emissions.

Four factors will make 2016 a turning point for policymakers, clean energy providers, and wholesale market operators to work together and modernize America’s regulated wholesale power markets:

1. The opportunity: markets can expose the value of co-optimizing power supply and demand

Grid flexibility is more important than ever, and resources capable of providing flexibility services at the right times will grow in value over the next decade.

Energy Information Administration data shows nine states received more than 10 percent of their electricity from variable renewables (wind and solar) in 2014. This renewables trend is on an upward trajectory, boosted by the recent extension of federal tax credits and several new state-level targets. Luckily, as the generation mix becomes more variable, dispatching demand is also becoming possible, opening up new opportunities to optimize the system—and save money doing so. For example, PJM Interconnection saw an 85 percent capacity price drop when demand response entered the market, and this week’s U.S. Supreme Court decision on FERC vs. Electric Power Suppliers Association further solidifies demand response’s footing in wholesale energy markets. And even before the favorable decision, Navigant was projecting the market for demand response would grow 600 percent in the next ten years.

Wholesale power markets have an opportunity to establish a level playing field now for all technologies to compete to provide these flexibility services, resulting in a cleaner, more cost-effective, capable grid.

The Midcontinent Independent System Operator, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, and theCalifornia Independent System Operator are developing new flexibility products in 2016, and have been working on updated rules to expand the types of resources qualified to participate. The results of these initial measures will expose the untapped potential for low-cost flexibility and illuminate important new directions for wholesale power markets.

2. The threat: New technology is hitting the grid—if markets don’t capture the opportunity now, they’ll have to cope later

Germany was ahead of the U.S. on solar deployment and may be a harbinger for what happens when markets are late to modernize. Solar pulled the rug out from under traditional generators as it flooded the market with zero marginal cost power during previously high-priced hours, causing severe financial pain for existing market participants without taking steps at the same time to value flexibility. This was unnecessary and may drive up the costs of Germany’s energy transition. Now, the nation is looking for ways to go back and place higher value on flexible resources in its markets.

2016 is the year to lay the groundwork for a more orderly transition in this country, one in which all resources (both supply- and demand-side) compete on equal footing to provide needed capabilities, creating a cost-effective, reliable system primed to rely more and more on clean energy.

3. The need for collaboration: Utilities are grappling with new business models—understanding the value of new services can help

New utility models have gotten all the buzz, and as utilities build business models focused on delivering value to customers, they are considering which new services they can offer. In regions with restructured markets, clear roles will need to be defined at the boundary between the transmission system and the distribution system—and this will begin to happen in 2016.

The value of new services aggregated at the distribution scale should depend on the value of services at the transmission scale, and vice versa. This will make the distribution service provider’s relationship with the regional grid operator even more important, and proactive utilities will put themselves in a better position by working together with grid operators now to plan for and operate a more integrated grid.

4. The why now: Pilots, policies, and plans in 2016 will shape the next decade or more

Conversations about wholesale power markets can be complex, but 2016 is the year for policymakers and clean energy providers to jump in with both feet. Pilot flexibility products are being tested this year and the technologies that show up early in these markets can help shape expanded markets while growing new revenue streams.

This week’s landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision supports demand response participation in wholesale energy markets, and will have ripple effects on how markets evolve and how other distributed energy technologies get paid. At the same time, a new Western wholesale power market may begin to emerge this year and its design will affect the overall costs, reliability, and carbon content of the Western grid.

Finally, who can forget the elephant in the room? The Clean Power Plan (CPP) codifies many of the trends already moving America toward a cleaner electric system. The CPP accelerates the inevitable onrush of new technologies, new ways of operating the grid, and new utility business models. It’s cheaper and more reliable to run a grid that takes advantage of diverse resources over broader geographic regions, and smoother coordination and trading in regions with wholesale power markets can result in better use of existing assets, keeping costs low as coal plants retire and our air gets cleaner.

This year’s pilots, policies, and plans will set the pattern for market development over many years to come. Now is the time to lay the groundwork for the system we want to see.

Feature image courtesy of

Photo via Flickr


No discussions yet. Start a discussion below.

America's Power Plan's picture
Thank America's for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »