This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.


Morocco Climate Talks: Five Things That Must Happen

David Hone's picture
Chief Climate Change Adviser Shell International Ltd.

David Hone serves as the Chief Climate Change Advisor for Royal Dutch Shell. He combines his work with his responsibilities as a board member of the International Emissions Trading Association...

  • Member since 2018
  • 420 items added with 202,724 views
  • Nov 9, 2016


As government ministers prepare to meet in Morocco, one year after the United Nations Paris agreement on climate change, Shell’s climate change adviser David Hone outlines the steps he believes are needed to make further progress.

There have been many surprising developments in the Paris agreement on climate change. The most recent was that it will enter into force on November 4 2016, setting new records for the speed of international diplomacy.

That happened after 55 countries, including the USA, China, Canada, India and Germany ratified the deal. The European parliament then followed suit. Now, as negotiators and ministers prepare to meet at the next United Nations climate conference in Marrakech, Morocco, it’s time to look at the small print, or the 20 pages of decision text.

Make no mistake. These, to me, are the critical pages. They are effectively the instruction manual for the agreement. They invite nations to act, recommend courses of action, decide on dates for delivery and ensure nations honour commitments. There is no room for interpretation and changes. The instructions are there to create mechanisms for reducing emissions work.

Of all the steps that need to be taken, for me there are five that stand out. To keep the deal on track, it is my belief that these must all be delivered in the near term, or before 2020.

Grandiose promise must become hard numbers

The decision text notes that combined action to reduce emissions specified by the 196 nations before they gathered in Paris falls far short of the goals of the agreement itself, to limit climate warming to well below 2° Celsius. That means that governments should take stock of their actions in 2018, and assess their progress. This will involve considerably more than a simple review. While the Paris agreement demonstrated a new political consensus on climate change, the same countries now have just two years to turn their promises into hard numbers.

No more vagueness. Deadlines must be set

After this stock-take in 2018, the pressure to deliver will only intensify. By 2020, nations will have to reformulate their actions. This will require prompt and probably challenging discussions on a national level. It isn’t just that the combined national actions falls short of the Paris agreement. Today, barely a single one of the plans appears in line with the ambitious goal that emerged on December 12 2015. Only Costa Rica comes close with its landmark proposal to be carbon-neutral by 2100.

Precise numbers have to be clarified

The Paris agreement moved the global goalposts when negotiators agreed to limit warming to well below 2° Celsius. But there could be more to come. The agreement offers a so-called stretch goal to limit warming to 1.5° Celsius and gives the science community just two years to establish how that might be achieved. Such a goal requires emissions to fall dramatically over the next 30 years. It could even mean the establishment of industries in the second half of the century that remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

Countries must adapt their energy transition timetables

The parties to the agreement have just four years to formulate how they will develop economy-wide strategies for lowering carbon emissions through to the middle of the century. These strategies must take into account the goals of the Paris agreement and therefore should draw on the work outlined above, which is not due until 2018. Even for the most advanced economies, plans that stretch over decades outlining the direction of energy systems are a tall order, given the uncertainties historically surrounding energy planning.

It’s time to talk about government-led carbon pricing systems

Arguably, the single most important step that governments can take to achieve the goal of the Paris agreement is to implement public policy that places a cost on carbon dioxide emissions. Some may think of this as the business of national or regional governments. But it’s worth thinking about how national currencies work. They are exchangeable around the world according to clear global rules. Article 6 of the Paris agreement offers the opportunity for similar rules for government-led carbon pricing systems, bringing much-needed alignment between the various systems. But Article 6, like the rest of the agreement, is brief. The negotiators now have to turn this into a functioning trading mechanism. This is no small task. But it is a vital one.

Original Post

Thorkil Soee's picture
Thorkil Soee on Nov 9, 2016

Sure: We can not wait much longer.
But we will never reach the goal without Nuclear.

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Nov 10, 2016

David, some folks seem to live for accords, for the instructions “to create mechanisms for reducing emissions work”, whatever that means. This, although accords have never resulted in significant carbon reductions, and likely never will.

Almost makes one think the primary function of fossil fuel companies in these efforts is diversion – to create the illusion of progress and prolong business-as-usual, as they send climate and biodiversity to hell. Would that be an accurate characterization?

David Hone's picture
Thank David for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »