This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.

Post

Electrifying school buses will benefit local economy and children’s health

image credit: Pixabay
Jennifer Rennicks's picture
Senior Manager of Government Affairs World Resources Institute
  • Member since 2020
  • 5 items added with 1,376 views
  • Jul 19, 2021 4:06 pm GMT
  • 702 views

After a school year like no other, Georgia’s students are well into their summer vacations. The diesel school buses that carry nearly half of America’s students sit idle, giving children and communities a break from breathing the unhealthy air pollution these buses spread. There’s substantial evidence that breathing diesel fumes puts children and their still-developing bodies at risk for damaged lungs, asthma and other respiratory diseases, cognitive impairment, and increased hospitalizations. It also increases their lifetime risk of developing lung and other cancers.

However, bold leadership by Congress this year could ensure that an infrastructure bill includes funding to accelerate the transition of school bus fleets to clean electric buses. This would ensure cleaner air for our students and communities. Here’s why it matters to all of us:

Your access to Member Features is limited.

It’s well documented that air pollution harms health, especially children’s health. Air pollution affects children from infancy through the teen years. It causes asthma attacks and increases their risk of developing asthma. It increases risk for viral illnesses such as influenza and COVID-19. It damages children’s and teens’ lung growth so they end up with lungs 10% smaller, setting them up for a lifetime of health problems. Air pollution also impairs learning at school, with lower test scores and more behavioral incidents. Diesel buses add to the air pollution levels in a city, affecting everyone’s health.

Studies show that children riding inside diesel school buses are exposed to up to four times the level of diesel exhaust as someone riding in a car ahead of the bus. The health implications for children are troubling, but school bus exhaust harms everyone in the community. And air pollution does not affect all people equally. Black and brown communities suffer first and worst from transportation pollution, because our country built highways, railyards, and trucking depots in or near their neighborhoods. This environmental racism increases exposure to air pollution and the risks of disease and early death.

But there is hope. Electric school buses are available and produce no tailpipe emissions. This means students and their communities can be served without harmful pollution. Electric buses are less polluting than diesel buses, even though some of our electricity still comes from fossil fuels. As the electricity grid gets cleaner, electric school buses will too. Switching from diesel to electric school buses could avoid about 5.3 million tons of greenhouse gas emissions each year according to the US Public Interest Research Group.

Health benefits aren’t the only ones Georgians will see from converting school bus fleets. Macon-based Blue Bird Corp. is an industry innovator creating hundreds of new jobs producing electric buses. In addition to jobs and investments in our communities, school district budgets will ultimately benefit from electric school buses’ lower maintenance costs and reduced fueling costs.

Despite numerous advantages for deploying electric school buses, purchasing them may pose a challenge for some of Georgia’s school districts that continue to face financial stress, specifically while addressing student transportation. So to help schools purchase these buses, Congress can support the Clean Commute for Kids Act, cosponsored by Georgia’s U.S. Sen. Raphael Warnock, which proposes to authorize $25 billion over the next 10 years for the Environmental Protection Agency, with assistance from the Department of Energy, to provide grants to replace existing buses with clean, zero-emission buses. Notably, 40% of this funding would go toward replacing school buses serving communities that have been hardest hit by the adverse impacts of climate change, including communities of color and rural communities. A recent study found that reducing school bus air pollution improved test scores as much as hiring a teacher with five years experience or having smaller class sizes, so assisting financially stressed school districts with EV school bus funding helps achieve their purpose of educating students.

Electrifying school buses and other bus fleets is just one form of electrifying transportation, with more opportunities for Georgia to lead the way. In May, Heliox, a Netherlands-based company that makes fast-charging systems for electric vehicles, announced Atlanta as its North American headquarters. South Korean company SK Innovation has already begun construction on a $2.6 billion manufacturing facility in Commerce, expected to employ up to 2,600 people manufacturing electric vehicle batteries. With additional state and federal policies to encourage the transition to electric transportation, we would expect to see more manufacturing investments and jobs created, as well as continued improvements in public health from cleaner vehicles.

As a pediatrician who specializes in air pollution, climate, and environmental health and as an advocate researching clean energy, we know that electrifying school buses is a win-win-win for Georgia: less air pollution, improved health, reduced fuel and maintenance budgets, and more well-paying jobs.

As we approach the end of one public health crisis caused by COVID-19, let’s not ignore another public health crisis caused by transportation pollution. Instead let’s urge Congress, state leaders, and our school districts to invest in our children and economy and begin the transition to electric school buses.

Jennifer Rennicks's picture
Thank Jennifer for the Post!
Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.
More posts from this member
Discussions
Spell checking: Press the CTRL or COMMAND key then click on the underlined misspelled word.
Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Jul 19, 2021

These programs seem to have so much natural benefits built in, hard to believe there'd be detractors-- I suppose the main hurdle would be availability of capital? But that's where some federal funds directed to this are going to be doing some great work

Jennifer Rennicks's picture
Jennifer Rennicks on Jul 21, 2021

Yes Matt, the main 'opposition' if you can call it that is the up-front price to purchase the buses, because the health and the 'total cost of ownership' savings speak for themselves. And yes, the federal funds through an infrastructure bill and/or a budget package are exactly what we need to kick start the transition.

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Jul 19, 2021

Good point, Jennifer. And after Vogtle reactors #3 - 4 go online over the next year, there will be 2,300 more megawatts of carbon-free electricity with which to charge them - energy that doesn't wait for the sun to shine, or the wind to blow.

Jennifer Rennicks's picture
Jennifer Rennicks on Jul 21, 2021

And as we know - the electric grid is already less polluting to charge electric vehicles than gasoline or diesel to power internal combustion engines and our grid is getting cleaner all the time as more renewable and zero carbon energy sources are brought online.

Jim Stack's picture
Jim Stack on Jul 21, 2021

Great points Jennifer,   In our area of Arixmzona the rules for purchasing school buses only included the upfront cost. They don't factor in the 80% less maintenance or the lower fuel cost or the reduced air and lung pollution. We need life cycle costs in the purchasing decisions but can't seem to get that changed. 

   The buses are also perfect got V2G but that also does not get factored in. Someday we will get the policy changed but it is very hard and slow.  

Jennifer Rennicks's picture
Jennifer Rennicks on Jul 21, 2021

Really important points, Jim, because the 'total cost of ownership' for any electric vehicle (private car or transit/school bus) usually provides savings with the reduced maintenance, the lower and stable costs of fueling, not to mention the public health benefits to our communities and especially our children. And on V2G: yes! buses may be the perfect way to scale up these forms of mobile battery storage. There's an opportunity to change policy and fund this change right now through either the infrastructure bill and/or the budget package, so I encourage people to contact their US Senators and member of Congress to support federal funding through policies like the Clean Commute for Kids Act.

Nevelyn Black's picture
Nevelyn Black on Jul 27, 2021

I saw that Central Coast Community Energy (CCCE) is incentivizing the purchase of electric buses for local public schools and school districts in California.  But what's your take on comments that Biden’s proposal to electrify school buses falls short of what it would cost to implement?  Regarding the V2G potential, Zum and AutoGrid are planning to use the batteries of 10,000 electric school buses as an aggregated resource that can be used to help balance the supply and demand of energy on the grid.

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »