This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.

Post

Drought and ethanol crunch U.S. corn crop

There’s a lot of fear-mongering in the media about the impact of the U.S. drought on food production and what that means for the future. A look at the crop supply data, available from the USDA feed grains yearbook, tells the full story, and it is not about food, nor is it entirely about the drought.

The U.S. shifting from fueling animals with corn to fueling cars with corn. I wrote about this a few years ago in a piece in Momentum Magazine, and my colleague Chris Kucharik and I alluded to this inevitability in our 2008 paper on corn ethanol production and the Gulf of Mexico ‘Dead Zone’.

Corn production has close to doubled since the early 1980s due to technology, fertilizer and the like increasing crop yields, and to an ethanol-driven increase in planted area over the past decade. Thanks to the increase in production, the U.S. was, until a couple years ago, able to produce all the corn ethanol without really denting the total amount of feed produced (or the amount of what I’ve labelled sweeteners and others, which includes high-fructose corn syrup, seeds, glucose / dextrose, floor waxes, xathan gum, pens, lecithin, breakfast cereals, adhesive tape, etc; OK, I admit, I made one of those up, but seriously, only one, and I could be wrong, that one may actually come from corn).

Now, ethanol production is coming at the expense of feed and exports. Last year, feed production was the lowest since 1995, which was a low corn production year, and exports were at the lowest since 2006. In the 2008 paper, we predicted this would happen simply because of land availability. There’s only so much productive cropland not already needed to for other grains and oils that can be used to produce high-yielding corn. In order to reach the goal of 15 billion gallons of corn-based ethanol per year, corn would have to be diverted from its other major uses, namely feed and exports. I’d like to claim I was brilliantly prescient, but the math was pretty straight-forward (though very very time-consuming to do properly, a reminder that science is often about the grunt work, not the exciting discovery).

This year, despite the devastating drought, there’s still plenty of corn being produced. Total corn production is right at the level of the middle of the last decade (the 2003-2007 average, to be precise). The supply issue is about ethanol, which is expected to use up almost 42% of this year’s corn crop (figure at left). The drought is exacerbating the effect of ethanol production on the availability of crops for other uses. According to the USDA’s preliminary estimates for the 2012/2013 crop year (the last set of data on the chart above, listed as 2012 for convenience), the drought will drop overall corn production by about 13% from the previous year, but ethanol production will only drop by 3%. Feed production  will be the lowest since the 1988 drought, a low level not generally seen since the 1970s. Similarly, exports will be the second lowest since 1980. The tight supply of feed and decline in exports, together with speculation about those same two things, is affecting prices, which can in turn affect food availability in other parts of the world.

There’s been much talk of whether this year’s drought and any impending price-driven food crisis can be linked to climate change. That’s impossible to answer definitively. Instead, we should think about the following: This year is an example of how poor climate change mitigation decisions – corn ethanol production, an answer that was looking for a question – can make the world less resilient to climate change.

Simon Donner's picture

Thank Simon for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.

Discussions

fred schumacher's picture
fred schumacher on Aug 24, 2012 6:52 pm GMT

I have several questions:

-- where are distillers grains included on the graph, if at all;

-- is the drop in crop fraction going to feed a result of use of distillers grains and/or a shift to more poultry production, which is seven times as efficient as beef in converting grain to meat;

-- how great is the importance of ethanol as an octane booster for cheaper to refine low-octane gasoline and how much of this blenders' activity is driving actual use of ethanol separate from any mandates?

My neighbor across the street here in Mankato is the corn buyer for Poet, which has 27 ethanol plant (including one cellulosic plant) in seven states and produces 1.6 billion gallons of ethanol per year along with 9 billion pounds of high protein distillers grains. He said production is already dropping off because of the drought and high corn prices. I don't think 42% of the corn crop will end up in ethanol this year. The market is already responding.

Bart Blake's picture
Bart Blake on Aug 24, 2012 9:21 pm GMT

I was wondering the same thing as Fred. If your graph only accounts for the use of raw corn for animal feed production, could it be that the use of distillers grains makes up the difference? Maybe the same amount of animal feed is being produced, but much of it now comes from the ethanol plants rather than raw corn.

Simon Donner's picture
Simon Donner on Aug 25, 2012 4:29 pm GMT

The graphs are based on the latest USDA projections for this year, which take into account assumed drop in corn production, and does not consider DDG use in feed. In the analysis for the 2008 paper I mention, we looked at how the use of DDGs as feed grains can offset some of the decline in feed availability that comes from shifting corn over to ethanol production. With the current estimates of DDG to feed use, I think there's a ~30-40% feed bonus from ethanol production. That does change the numbers in this post, but it would only bump feed production from this year up to the level it was at five years ago. The basic idea, that using corn for ethanol diverts corn from other uses, thus making corn availability and the market in general more sensitive to drought.

fred schumacher's picture
fred schumacher on Aug 25, 2012 4:55 pm GMT

If distillers grains are not included on the graph, a "raw corn equivalent" needs to be added since the high protein nature of distillers grain makes it more efficient feed than raw corn, thus a simple bulk quantity would not show its true contribution to livestock feeding. If feed quantity had really dropped off to the degree shown on the graph, we would have had major meat shortages, something that has not happened.

Quentin Prideaux's picture
Quentin Prideaux on Aug 29, 2012 3:45 am GMT

"There's been much talk of whether this year's drought and any impending price-driven food crisis can be linked to climate change. That's impossible to answer definitively. Instead, we should think about the following: This year is an example of how poor climate change mitigation decisions - corn ethanol production, an answer that was looking for a question - can make the world less resilient to climate change.'


OK, I'd forgotten how hopeless this blog is.  My last post, removing you from my RSS.

*Instead* of wondering why we've just had our 360th consecutive month of temperatures above average, the hottest month the USA has ever seen, drought, fires, tornadoes in Massachusetts, thousands of counties in disaster status, and collapsing ice cover.....yes, let's think of something MORE important than that.  Some thing that distracts us from the truth.  Something that says we're not (*&#ing the planet daily with 90 million tons of greenhouse gas pollution.  Get your fiddle, Nero.

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »